Menus
- All Day Menu
- Happy Hour
- Croton Cocktails
- Draft Beer, Bottles & Cans
- Wines
- Spirits
- Old & Rare
- Allergy Menu
Check out Croton Reservoir Tavern's menu and taste the best of Midtown—just click the link below!
Certainly! Here’s the menu organized without bold text:
---
SHAREABLES
Sliders (Minimum of 3, no mixing)
Beef Slider - $16
Cheddar, tomato, pickle
Pulled Pork Slider - $16
Slaw
Veggie Slider - $16
Tomato jam, romaine, roasted garlic crema
Wings
6 for $14 or 12 for $26
50/50: Buffalo BBQ, pepper relish, Alabama white sauce
Classic Buffalo: House blue cheese, celery
Dry Rubbed: 11 spices, creamy ranch
Crispy Calamari - $22
Avocado-jalapeno salsa verde
Cast Iron Shrimp - $23
sauteed shrimp, grilled country bread, white wine, garlic butter
Crispy Brussels - $18
Whipped feta, pickled shallots, candied pecans, hot honey
Artichoke Dip - $18
Cream cheese, parmesan, cheddar jack, artichokes, paprika, house pita
NYC Mega Pretzel - $16
Stone ground mustard, beer cheese sauce
Skillet Nachos - $18
Corn and bean chili, pico de gallo, guacamole, chipotle sour cream, corn tortilla, beer cheese sauce
Bang Bang! - $16
“Szechuan style” cauliflower, sesame, green onion, red pepper
Return of the Mac - $18
Shells, cheddar, gouda, jack, garlic breadcrumbs
Hummus - $16
Harissa, evoo, garlic, onion, pico de gallo, house pita
TACOS AND FLATTBREAS
Brisket Tacos - $18
Onion, tomatillo sauce, cilantro
Chicken Tacos - $16
Braised chicken, pickled onion, cilantro, tomatillo sauce
Pork Carnitas Tacos - $16
Pulled pork, slaw, pickled onions, cilantro, tomatillo sauce
Roasted Garlic Flatbread - $18
Spicy yogurt sauce, roasted mushrooms, garlic puree, herb pesto, everything bagel seasoning
Margherita Flatbread - $18
Plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, evoo
Short Rib Flatbread - $20
House-made spicy red sauce, burrata cheese, fresh tomato, red onion, basil, evoo
BURGERS
CRT Burger - $23
Gorgonzola, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, brioche bun
Tavern Burger - $21
White cheddar, lettuce, tomato, brioche bun
Veggie Burger - $20
Jalapenos, grilled red onion, tomato jam, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, onion roll
HANDHELDS
Beer Belly Pulled Pork - $20
Bourbon BBQ, slaw, pickles, brioche bun
Grilled Cheese and Tomato Bisque - $22
Toasted country bread, pepper jack cheese, cheddar cheese, tomato bisque
Croton Crunch - $22
Spicy fried chicken, house chili onion crunch, slaw, pickles, brioche
Grilled Chicken Wrap - $20
Herb marinated chicken, bacon, avocado, Swiss cheese, shredded romaine, tomato, house chipotle ranch, whole wheat wrap
Braised Brisket - $23
Onion, cheddar cheese, bacon, jalapenos, yogurt spread, toasted sourdough, jus
GARDEN GREENS & BOWLS
The Cobb - $21
Mesclun, grilled chicken, crumbled bacon, blue cheese, egg, avocado, tomato, herb vinaigrette
All Hail Caesar - $16
Romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, Caesar dressing
Ahi Tuna Bowl - $30
Sriracha tuna, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, mango, crispy onions, sticky rice, furikake
Mediterranean Bowl - $19
Chopped romaine, cucumber, tomato, pickled red onion, chickpeas, kalamata olives, sticky rice, feta and herb dressing
Green Goddess - $18
Baby gem lettuce, shaved Brussels sprouts, red cabbage, roasted caramelized carrots, sunflower seeds
**Add-ons for Handhelds and Salads:**
Chicken - $9
Shrimp - $12
Salmon - $14
Hanger Steak - $14
TAVERN FAVORITES
Crispy Skin Salmon - $34
Ancient grains, braised greens, apple butter, apple, herb salad
Steak Frites - $35
Grilled hanger, house frites, roasted shallot red wine demi
Roast Chicken - $31
Pastrami spiced chicken, whipped potatoes, sautéed broccolini, chicken jus
Cacio Pepe - $29
Ravioli, peas, oyster mushrooms, cream sauce
Ribeye - $46
16oz bone-in ribeye, brown butter carrot puree, wild mushrooms, pearl onions
SOUPS AND SIDES
Tomato Bisque - $12
Please ask your server about our freshly made soup
**Sides**
Basket of Sweet Fries - $10
Basket of Hand Cut Fries - $11
Mashed Potatoes - $11
Sautéed Broccolini - $10
Side Salad - $10
**Follow Us**
@crotonnyc
4PM - 8PM | Tuesday - Thursday Lower Level Lounge
Download PDFHappy Hour
-
Mango Habanero Margarita
$12
-
Classic Margarita
$10
-
Old Fashioned
$12
-
Manhattan
$12
-
Sangria
$10
-
Cosmopolitan
$12
-
Aperol Spritz
$12
-
Select Wines
Cabernet, sauvignon blanc
$10
-
Draft Beer
off normal price $2
-
Well Drinks
$10
Shareables
-
New York Pretzel
Served with stone ground mustard, local beer cheese
$15
-
Skillet Nachos
corn and bean chili, pico de gallo, guacamole, chipotle sour cream, corn tortilla, beer cheese sauce
$18
Add chicken $9
Steak $14
Shrimp $12
-
Artichoke Dip
Cream cheese, parmesan, cheddar jack, artichokes, paprika, house pita
$18
-
hummus
Harissa, (evoo), garlic, onion, pico de gallo, house pita
$16
-
Crispy Calamari
Avocado, jalapenos, salsa verde
$22
-
Cast Iron Shrimp
White wine, garlic butter, chile, grilled country bread
6c $23
12c $39
-
Mini Burger Sliders
Beef, pulled pork or veggie sliders
$16
-
Bang Bang!
"Szechuan" style cauliflower, sesame, green onion, red chilies
Bowl $16
Platter $28
-
Roasted Garlic Flatbread
Spicy yogurt sauce, roasted mushrooms, garlic puree, herb pesto, everything bagel seasoning
$18
-
Margherita Flatbread
Plum tomato sauce, mozzarella, basil, evoo
$18
-
Short Rib Flatbread
House made spicy red sauce, burrata cheese, fresh tomato, red onion, basil, evoo
$20
-
Wings
Buffalo, barbecue, or dry rub
6c $14
12c $26
24c $50
-
Tenders
Breaded chicken tenders served with house sauces
6c $12
12c $22
24c $42
-
Hand Cut Fries
$11
Truffle $4
Truffle Parm $5
-
Sweet Potato Fries
$12
Signatures
-
Paloma Pop (taptail)
Croton tequila, passion fruit, grapefruit, lemongrass, Aperol, soda, served tall over ice
$17
-
Eternal Sprimg
Ford's gin, elderflower, kiwi-cucumber cordial, lime, served on the rocks
$17
-
Mango Habanero Margarita
Croton tequila, mango, habanero tincture, lime, served on the rocks
$17
-
Passionista
Croton vodka, pineapple, passion fruit, lemon, served up
$19
-
Strawberry Frosé (Slushy)
Rose & Sauternes, rum peach & strawberry mistelle, Gewürztraminer eau- de-vie, elderflower, served very cold
$18
-
Loch’d & Loaded
Compass Box "Artist Blend" scotch, Midori melon liqueur, Italicus bergamot, saline, lemon, served over a large cube
$19
-
Spiced Pear Tart
Basil Hayden bourbon, pear-honey shrub, lemon, habanero tincture, served over a large cube
~ Ask about our Seasonal Sangria and Spritz Options ~$18
Alcohol Free
-
Mystic Mango
Lyre’s N/A agave blanco, mango, maraschino cherry, habanero tincture, saline, lime, served over a large cube
$14
-
Garden Dreams
Seedlip garden 108, pear shrub, hibiscus, rosemary, thyme, lemon, soda water, served tall in a Collins glass
$14
Classics & Reserves
-
1842 Manhattan
Basil Hayden bourbon, Great Jones NY Rye, Pierre Ferrand 1840 cognac, sweet vermouth, fonseca 27 port, Averna amaro, bitters, served up
$21
-
Reserve 50/50 Sazerac
10 Générations Ferrand 1er Cru Cognac, Pappy “Old Rip ” Van Winkle Rye, sugar, absinthe, Peychaud ’s bitters, served in a chilled absinthe rinsed glass
$65
-
Reserve Old Fashioned
Yamazaki 12 yr bourbon, sugar, Angostura & orange bitters, served over a large cube
$20
-
Big Apple Boulevardier
Great Jones NY bourbon, campari, apple, Carpano Antica, Amaro Nonino, served over a large cube
$20
Martinis
-
Fancy Apple Martini
Croton vodka, sour apple, soursop, lemon, served up
$20
-
Mexican Gimlet
Maestro Dobel tequila, seedlip, thyme, rosemary, aloe, frsh cucumber, lime & lime oil, served up
$20
-
Super Cosmo
Croton vodka, cranberry-grenadine, pomegranate, lemongrass, fresh lime, served up
$19
-
Butterscotch Espresso Martini
Espresso infused vodka, Borghetti espresso liqueur, creme de cacao, almond orgeat, butterscotch, Nice Day cold brew, served up
$19
Draft
-
7-Line Ale
5.5% $9
-
Bronx Well Earned Pilsner
5.5% $9
-
Peroni
4.7% $9
-
Stella Artois
5.0% $9
-
Croton Lager
4.4% $8
-
Blue Point Toasted Lager
4.8% $9
-
Kona Big Wave Golden Ale
4.4% $9
-
Blue Moon Belgium Style Witbier
5.4% $9
-
Goose Island IPA
5.9% $9
-
Beer Hug Hazy IPA
6.8% $9
-
Devil’s Path IPA
7.5% $10
-
Montauk Wave Chaser IPA
6.4% $9
-
Victory Golden Monkey Belgium Ale
9.5% $11
-
Duvel
8.5% $12
-
Guiness Stout
4.2% $10
Bottles, Cans, & Crushables
-
Amstel Light
3.5% $7
-
Michelob Ultra
4.2% $7
-
Bud Light
4.2% $7
-
Coors Light
4.2% $7
-
Budweiser
5.0% $7
-
Downeast Cider
5.1% $8
-
Wolffer Rose Cider
6.9% $10
-
Corona
4.6% $8
-
Heineken
5.0% $8
-
Sloop Juice Bomb NEIPA
6.5% $10
-
Other Half Green City IPA
7.0% $10
-
Surfside (Lemonade, Iced Tea)
4.5% $8
-
White Claw Mango
5.0% $8
-
High Noon Grapefruit
4.5% $10
-
Montauk Summer Ale
5.6% $8
-
Heineken Zero
MA $7
White Wine
Sauvignon Blanc
-
The Crossings, 2022, Marlborough, New Zealand
Glass $17
Bottle $64
-
Indaba, 2022, Western Cape, South Africa
Glass $14
Bottle $52
-
Le Roi des Pierres, Sancerre “Silex”, 2023, Loire Valley, France
Glass $19
Bottle $72
Pinot Grigio
-
Villa Puccini, 2020, Veneto, Italy
Glass $15
Bottle $56
Riesling
-
Hogue, 2022, Columbia Valley, Washington
Glass $15
Bottle $56
Chardonnay
-
Sea Sun by Caymus Vinyards, 2020, California
Glass $15
Bottle $56
-
ELOUAN, 2021, Oregon
$60
Rosé / Skin Contact
-
Domaine Paul Buisse, “Rosé de Loire”, 2021, Loire, Valley
Glass $14
Bottle $52
-
Chateau D’Esclans, “Whispering Angel”, 2023, Provence, France
Glass $16
Bottle $60
-
Studio by “Miraval”, 2023
Glass $15
Bottle $55
-
Belle Glos “Oeil D Oedrix”, 2022, Sonoma County, California
$66
Bubbles
-
Prosecco DOC, Clara C, Veneto, Italy
Glass $15
Bottle $56
-
Sparkling, Domaine Chandon Brut, NV, California, 187 ml
Glass $20
Bottle
-
Sparkling, Domaine Chandon Brut Rosè, NV, California, 187 ml
Glass $20
Bottle
-
Champagne, Veuve Clicquot, NV, France
$130
Port
-
Graham’s Tawny Port 20 yr
$16
-
Ferreira Dona Antonia Reserva Tawny Port
$15
-
Taylor Fladgate Tawny Port 20 yr
$20
-
Taylor Fladgate Fine Tawny Port
$15
Red Wine
Pinot Noir
-
Chateau Haut-Blanville, “Grand Reserve”, 2021, France
Glass $15
Bottle $56
-
Boen, 2021, Central Coast, California
Glass $17
Bottle $64
Barbaresco
-
Villadoria DOCG, 2020, Piedmont, Italy
$80
Malbec
-
Reserva, Terrazas de los Andres, 2021, Mendoza Argentina
$75
-
Altos del Plata, Terrazas de los Andres, 2022, Mendoza Argentina
Glass $14
Bottle $52
Cabernet
-
Excelsior, 2021, Western Cape, South Africa
Glass $14
Bottle $52
-
Decoy by Duckhorn, 2021, Napa Valley, California
$90
-
Faust, 2018, Napa Valley, California
$180
-
Banshee, 2020, Sonoma County, California
$75
-
Caymus, 2019, Napa Valley, California
$225
-
Bonanza by Caymus Vineyards, Lot 6, California
Glass $17
Bottle $64
Red Blend
-
Unshackled by Prisoner Wine Co., 2019, Oakville, California
$88
-
The Prisoner by The Prisoner wine Co., 2021, Oakville, California
$160
Whisky
Japan-
Hakushu 12yr
$45
-
Hibiki Harmony
$25
-
Hibiki 21yr
$120
-
Nikka Coffee Malt
$21
-
Nikka Coffee Oak
$22
-
Nikka Days
$18
-
Nikka From The Barrel
$26
-
Nikka Miyagiko
$25
-
Nikka Taketsuru 17yr
$65
-
Nikka Taketsuru 21yr
$85
-
Nikka Yoichi
$27
-
Suntory Toki
$17
-
Yamazaki 12yr
$38
Canada
-
Canadian Club
$14
-
Caribou Crossing Small Batch
$16
-
Crown Royal
$15
-
Lot 40
$17
-
Pike Creek
$15
-
Masterson’s 10yr
$28
-
Seagram Seven
$14
Ireland
-
Bushmill’s
$15
-
Bushmill’s Black Bush
$16
-
Fighting 69
$18
-
Green Spot 12yr by Mitchell & Son
$22
-
Yellow Spot 12yr by Mitchell & Son
$29
-
Red Spot 15yr by Mitchell & Son
$45
-
Blue Spot 7yr by Mitchell & Son
$42
-
Lost Irish
$15
-
Jameson
$15
-
Jameson Black
$16
-
Jameson 12yr
$35
-
Jameson 18yr Gold
$45
-
Redbreast 12yr
$21
-
Redbreast 15yr
$30
-
Redbreast 21yr
$65
-
Redbreast Lustau
$32
-
Teeling
$16
-
Writer’s Tears
$18
Bourbon & Whiskey
-
1792 Full Proof
$20
-
Amador Double Barrel Cabernet Finish
$20
-
Amador Double Barrel Chardonnay Finish
$17
-
Amador Double Barrel Port Finish
$24
-
Angel’s Envy Bourbon
$18
-
Bardstown Discovery Series
$35
-
Bardstown Fusion Kentucky Straight Bourbon
$22
-
Bardstown Original Series
$19
-
Basil Hayden
$16
-
Basil Hayden 10yr
$22
-
Basil Hayden Toasted
$22
-
Blade & Bow
$21
-
Bookers 2023-03 ‘Mighty Fine Batch’ 6yr
$28
-
Bowman Single Barrel
$19
-
Bowman Small Batch
$18
-
Brother’s Bond Original Cask Strength
$23
-
Buffalo Trace
$17
-
Bulleit
$18
-
Eagle Rare 10yr
$22
-
Elijah Craig 18yr
$52
-
Evan Williams White Label
$15
-
Gentleman Jack
$18
-
Great Jones Distillery
$17
Try our collection of rare bourbon, scotch and rye
Download PDF-
Baker's 13yr
$32
-
Blanton's
$26
-
Orphan Barrel 14yr Castle's Curse
$39
-
Elmer T. Lee
$25
-
EH Taylor Small Batch
$25
-
EH Taylor Single Barrel
$35
-
Stagg Jr.
$32
-
George T. Stagg 116.9
$70
-
George T. Stagg 135
$70
-
George T. Stagg 138.7
$70
-
Jack Daniels's 10 yr
$31
-
Jack Daniel's 12yr
$38
-
Pappy 'Old Rip' Van Winkle 10yr
$55
-
Pappy Van Winkle 12yr Special Reserve
$75
-
Pappy Van Winkle 15yr
$120
-
Russel's Reserve Rye Single Barrel
$33
-
Russel's Reserve 13yr
$35
-
Rock Hill Farms
$29
-
Widow Jane Decadence
$32
-
W. L. Weller 12yr
$34
-
W.L. Weller Antique 107
$32
-
W.L. Weller Special Reserve
$21
-
W.L Weller Full Proof
$38
-
W.L. Weller Single Barrel
$65
-
W.L. Weller CYPB
$65
-
Elijah Craig Straight Rye
$18
-
High West Midwinter Dram
$36
-
Glenlivet 18yr
$42
-
Glenlivet 21yr
$65
-
Glenlivet Nadurra
$28
-
Glenlivet XXV
$125
-
Glenmorangie Nectar
$25
-
Glenmorangie Signet
$65
-
Port Dundas 12yr
$23
-
Port Dundas 18yr
$55
Please refer to this handout for all you questions about allergies and dietary restrictions. To be safe, please notify you server of any dietary considerations!
Download PDFShareables
-
Crispy Calamari
Calamari, rice flour, potato starch, tomatillo, avocado, jalapenos, cilantro, lime, garlic, onion
shellfish
-
Crispy Brussel Sprouts
Brussels, feta cheese, shallots, vinegar, sugar, salt, pecans, honey, maple syrup, habanero peppers
dairy, nuts
-
Artichoke Dip
Artichoke hearts, parmesan, garlic, tabasco, lemon juice, cheddar jack, scallions
dairy, gluten
-
Nyc Mega Pretzel
Flour, yeast, salt, cheese, beer, seasoning spices
dairy, gluten
-
Beef Slider
Potato bun, 2.5oz beef patty, hawaiian bread, cheddar cheese, pickles
dairy, gluten
-
Pulled Pork Slider
potato bun, pulled pork, BBQ sauce, slow cooked in oil, garlic, thyme, bay leaf, paprika, cayenne
dairy, gluten
-
Veggie Slider
Potato bun, tomato jam, iceberg, roasted garlic crema
gluten
-
Nacho Skillet
corn and bean chili, onion, garlic, tomato, cilantro, chipotle sour cream, beer cheese sauce, onion, avocados
dairy
-
BANG BANG! contains sesame
Cauliflower, coconut milk, cinnamon, cumin, salt and pepper, potato starch, flour, salt and pepper, cumin, soy, sesame seed, red pepper, rice flour
gluten
-
Chicken Wings
Rifed chicken wings, old bay, paprika, salt, pepper, garlic powder, onion powder
dairy
-
Cast Iron Shrimp
Shrimp, oil, garlic, red pepper flakes, white wine, béchamel, garlic butter, lemon juice, parsley, ciabatta
dairy, gluten, shellfish
-
Return of The Mac
Pasta shells, gruyere, asiago, bacon, kale, bread crumbs, scallions, cream
dairy, gluten
-
Hummus contains sesame
Chickpea, garlic, lemon juice, tahini, harissa, (evoo), garlic, onion, pico de gallo, house pita
dairy, gluten
Tacos
-
Brisket Tacos
Corn tortilla shell, short ribs, onion, tomatillo, cilantro
dairy
-
Chicken Tacos
Corn tortilla shell, braised chicken
-
Pork Carnitas
Pulled pork (dried Morita chili, onion, garlic, water) slaw, pickled onions, cilantro, tomatillo sauce
Handhelds
-
Beer Belly Pork Sandwhich
Braised pork butt, house bbq sauce, slaw, pickles, brioche bun
dairy, gluten
-
Crt Burger
8oz patty, gorgonzola, shredded romaine, roasted garlic crema, brioche bun
dairy, gluten
-
Tavern Burger
8oz burger, brioche bun, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato
dairy, gluten
-
Veggie Burger
Kidney beans, and roasted mushrooms, parsley, thyme, panko breadcrumb, ketchup, vinegar, onions, worcestershire, molasses, liquid smoke, garlic, avocado, lettuce, tomato
dairy, gluten
-
Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup
buttered sourdough, mozzarella cheese, cheddar cheese, tomato soup (roasted cherry tomatoes, garlic, onion, EVOO)
dairy, gluten
-
Croton Crunch contains egg
6oz chicken thigh, spicy fried chicken, house chili onion crunch, slaw, pickles, brioche
dairy, gluten
-
Grilled Chicken Wrap
8oz burger, brioche bun, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato
dairy, gluten
-
Braised Brisket
Short rib, onion, cheddar cheese, bacon, jalapenos, yogurt spread, onion roll, Jus
dairy, gluten
Sweet Tooth
-
Smores Please
Graham cracker cake, pecan, chocolate cremeux, toasted meringue
dairy, gluten, nuts
-
Caramel Apple Cheesecake
NY cheesecake, dolce de leche caramel, roasted red apples, whipped cream
dairy, gluten
-
Chocolate Fudge Cake
Chocolate fudge layer cake
dairy, gluten
-
Brownie Sundae
Vanilla ice cream, whip cream, chocolate sauce, sprinkles
dairy, gluten
-
Cookie Plate
Assorted cookies
dairy, gluten
Flatbread
-
Roasted Garlic Flatbread
Artichokes, cream cheese, parmesan, red onion, arugula
dairy, gluten
-
Margherita Flatbread
Plum tomato sauce, shredded mozzarella, grated parmesan, fresh basil, olive oil
dairy, gluten
-
Short Rib Flatbread
House made spicy red sauce, burrata cheese, fresh tomato, red onion, basil, evoo
dairy, gluten
Garden Greens
-
The Cobb
Red beets, golden beets, pecans, pickled parsnips (vinegar, salt, sugar), oranges, feta vinaigrette (mayonnaise, sour cream, feta, milk, garlic, dill, oregano, salt and pepper)
dairy, nuts
-
All Hail Caesar Contains Anchovy
Romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, focaccia croutons, caesar dressing
dairy, gluten
-
Ahi Tuna Bowl
sriracha, tuna, mayo, cucumber, edamame, pickled onion, mango, crispy onions, sticky rice, furikake
-
Mediterranean Bowl
Chopped romaine, cucumber, pickled red onion, cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, feta and herb dressing
dairy
-
Green Goddess
Shaved brussel sprouts, red cabbage, roasted caramelized carrots, sunflower seeds over gem lettuce
dairy
Large Plate
-
Steak Frites
8oz hanger, french fries, red wine, beef stock, flour, butter
dairy, gluten
-
Crispy Skin Salmon
Salmon, ancient grains, braised swiss chard, apple butter, apple and herb salad
dairy, gluten
-
Roast Chicken
Pastrami spiced (pepper, coriander, brown sugar, paprika, garlic powder, onion powder, mustard seed, mustard powder) chicken, potatoes, sautéed broccolini, chicken jus
dairy, gluten
-
Cacio Pepe Ravioli contains alcohol
Cheese filled ravioli, oyster mushroom, peas, cracked black pepper, pecorino, white wine cream sauce
dairy, gluten
-
Ribeye
16oz bone-in ribeye, brown butter carrot puree, wild mushrooms, pearl onions
dairy